Last updated: November 2, 2026 · By Eternal Elixir Editorial
Last updated: November 2, 2026 · By Eternal Elixir Editorial · 9 products compared
The front of Healthy Care Liver Care Advanced Plus says 42000mg. Each capsule holds 600 mg of milk thistle extract, and the 42,000 figure is the weight of dried fruit that the extract was made from. The same convention runs across the herbal range. Grape Seed 58000 holds 483.3 mg of grape seed extract, and Ginkgo High Strength 10000 holds 200 mg of ginkgo leaf extract. Both numbers are on the label, but the big one is what a shopper sees first, and it makes price comparisons hard.
Australians search for Healthy Care about 1,300 times a month, plus another 720 searches for “healthy care australia”, according to keyword-tool estimates checked in November 2026. The first page of results is the brand’s own store, its social pages and a reviews widget. No result compares the range with other brands on dose and daily cost, so we wrote this comparison of Healthy Care alternatives to do that job.
On 2 November 2026 we read the labels and live prices on healthycare.com.au for five Healthy Care products in categories where Eternal Elixir also makes a product: sleep and magnesium, stress and mood, liver health, and resveratrol. We worked out the daily cost of each at its own label directions and set four Eternal Elixir products against them. For the wider brand picture, our guide to top Australian supplement brands compares ten local companies by specialty.
Eternal Elixir makes four of the products on this list, and they are our picks. Every figure for the other products is taken from their own labels and the brand’s live online price.
Quick Answer
Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg is our top pick among Healthy Care alternatives in Australia because it uses the magnesium form tested for deep and REM sleep scores in a 2024 placebo-controlled trial, in one three-capsule serve a day for $2.00. For stress and mood, Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg is the best choice: 30 mg of affron® for $0.56 a day.
Based on live AUD prices and label directions for 9 products available in Australia, checked 2 November 2026
Not sure which suits you? Take the 60-second quiz and see the one Eternal Elixir product matched to your main goal, with its daily cost and how to take it.
Table of contents
- 1. Healthy Care Alternatives Compared: Dose and Daily Cost
- 2. What the Big Numbers on Healthy Care Labels Mean
- 3. #1. Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg — Best for brain-focused magnesium at night
- 4. #2. Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg — Best for daily stress and mood support
- 5. #3. Eternal Elixir TUDCA 500mg — Best for a bile acid approach to liver health
- 6. #4. Eternal Elixir Trans-Resveratrol 600mg — Best for the lowest cost per 100 mg of resveratrol
- 7. #5. Healthy Care Good Night Sleep (Magnesium + Ashwagandha) — Best for the lowest nightly price
- 8. #6. Healthy Care Magnesium Glycinate — Best for the most elemental magnesium per tablet
- 9. #7. Healthy Care L-Theanine + Ashwagandha — Best for L-theanine and ashwagandha in one tablet
- 10. #8. Healthy Care Liver Care Advanced Plus 42000mg — Best for a three-herb liver formula at $0.35 a day
- 11. #9. Healthy Care Resveratrol Capsule — Best for the lowest shelf price
- 12. Magnesium Dose Check: Healthy Care Labels Against the Daily Limit
- 13. How We Evaluated These Healthy Care Alternatives
- 14. Healthy Care Alternatives: Frequently Asked Questions
- 14.1. What is the best Healthy Care alternative in Australia?
- 14.2. Is Healthy Care a good brand?
- 14.3. What does 42000mg mean on Healthy Care Liver Care Advanced Plus?
- 14.4. Is Healthy Care cheaper than Eternal Elixir?
- 14.5. How much magnesium can I take from supplements each day?
- 14.6. Can I take magnesium L-threonate and saffron together?
- 14.7. How long should I try a supplement before judging it?
- 15. The Verdict on Healthy Care Alternatives
Healthy Care Alternatives Compared: Dose and Daily Cost
The table ranks nine products across four jobs: sleep and magnesium, stress and mood, liver health, and resveratrol. Price per day is the shelf price divided by the number of days a pack lasts at the label’s directions. Where a label gives a range, such as one to two capsules, both ends are shown.
| Rank | Product | Dose per day (label directions) | Price AUD | Price per day (AUD, at label dose) | AU Shipping | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg | 3 capsules, 2,000 mg magnesium L-threonate (about 144 mg elemental magnesium) | $59.99 (90 capsules) | $2.00 | Fast Australian dispatch, free over $100 | Best overall: the magnesium form studied for sleep and the brain |
| 2 | Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg | 1 capsule, 30 mg affron® saffron extract | $49.99 (90 capsules) | $0.56 | Fast Australian dispatch, free over $100 | Lowest daily price among the stress and mood products here |
| 3 | Eternal Elixir TUDCA 500mg | 1 capsule, 500 mg TUDCA | $59.99 (90 capsules) | $0.67 | Fast Australian dispatch, free over $100 | A single-ingredient bile acid for liver health |
| 4 | Eternal Elixir Trans-Resveratrol 600mg | 1 capsule, 600 mg trans-resveratrol | $59.99 (90 capsules) | $0.67 | Fast Australian dispatch, free over $100 | Lowest cost per 100 mg of resveratrol in this comparison ($0.11) |
| 5 | Healthy Care Good Night Sleep (Magnesium + Ashwagandha) | 1 to 2 capsules, 100 to 200 mg elemental magnesium plus four herbal extracts | $23.99 (100 capsules) | $0.24 to $0.48 | Online at healthycare.com.au (shipping fee not checked) | Lowest nightly price among the sleep products here |
| 6 | Healthy Care Magnesium Glycinate | 1 to 2 tablets, 160 to 320 mg elemental magnesium | $32.99 (120 tablets) | $0.27 to $0.55 | Online at healthycare.com.au (shipping fee not checked) | Most elemental magnesium per tablet in this list |
| 7 | Healthy Care L-Theanine + Ashwagandha | 1 tablet, 200 mg L-theanine and 240 mg ashwagandha extract | $35.99 (60 tablets) | $0.60 | Online at healthycare.com.au (shipping fee not checked) | L-theanine and ashwagandha in one daily tablet |
| 8 | Healthy Care Liver Care Advanced Plus 42000mg | 1 capsule, 600 mg milk thistle extract plus artichoke and dandelion | $35.09 (100 capsules) | $0.35 | Online at healthycare.com.au (shipping fee not checked) | Lowest daily cost among the ranked liver products |
| 9 | Healthy Care Resveratrol Capsule | 2 to 4 capsules, 50 to 100 mg resveratrol plus grape seed and vitamin C | $19.19 (180 capsules) | $0.21 to $0.43 | Online at healthycare.com.au (shipping fee not checked) | Lowest shelf price in this list |
Not sure what to take? Take our 8-question quiz
to unlock 20% OFF your entire first order
+ a FREE gift worth up to $59.99
Choose your goal to start the quiz
What the Big Numbers on Healthy Care Labels Mean
Most Healthy Care herbal products carry two weights. The first is the weight of extract in each capsule. The second is the weight of raw plant material that went into making that extract, written as “equivalent to dry fruit” or “equivalent to dry leaf”. The headline number on the front of the pack is the second one. Here is how it reads on the products most people search for.
| Healthy Care product | Headline number | Extract in each capsule | What the headline measures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liver Care Advanced Plus 42000mg | 42,000 mg | 600 mg milk thistle fruit extract | 42 g of dried milk thistle fruit, a 70 to 1 ratio |
| High Strength Grape Seed 58000 | 58,000 mg | 483.3 mg grape seed extract (460 mg procyanidins listed) | 58 g of dried grape seed |
| Ginkgo High Strength 10000mg | 10,000 mg | 200 mg ginkgo leaf extract | 10 g of dried ginkgo leaf |
| Resveratrol Capsule | No headline figure | 50 mg Reynoutria japonica root extract (25 mg resveratrol) | 5 g of fresh root |
| L-Theanine + Ashwagandha | No headline figure | 240 mg ashwagandha root extract | 10.8 g of dried root |
An extract ratio tells you how concentrated an extract is. It does not tell you how much of the active compound you get unless the label also gives a standardised amount. Two of these labels do: Grape Seed 58000 lists its procyanidins, and Liver Care Advanced Plus lists a silybin figure for its milk thistle. Compare herbal products on the extract weight and any standardised active, and read the equivalent figure as a description of the raw material.
Eternal Elixir labels give the weight of the compound itself: 2,000 mg of magnesium L-threonate per serve, 30 mg of affron®, 500 mg of TUDCA and 600 mg of trans-resveratrol. Grape seed is mostly bought for antioxidant support. If that is your reason for buying it, Eternal Elixir Reduced L-Glutathione 2000mg is our antioxidant pick at $39.99 for 45 two-capsule serves, or $0.89 a day, and our antioxidant supplements comparison sets it against other options.
#1. Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg — Best for brain-focused magnesium at night
Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg is our pick among Healthy Care alternatives for people who buy magnesium to sleep better. Healthy Care’s online store lists at least 16 products with magnesium in the name, from oxide-based Super Bio Magnesium to glycinate tablets and powders. Those forms are chosen to raise magnesium intake. Magnesium L-threonate binds magnesium to L-threonate, a metabolite of vitamin C, and it is the form researchers use when they study magnesium and the brain.
In a 2024 randomised, double-blind trial published in Sleep Medicine: X, 80 adults aged 35 to 55 with self-reported sleep problems took 1 g of magnesium L-threonate a day or a placebo for 21 days. Against placebo, the magnesium group improved on Oura ring deep sleep and REM sleep scores, and reported better mood, energy and mental alertness on waking. Three of the six authors worked for AIDP, a company that sells magnesium L-threonate, so read it as an encouraging early result. The trial used 1 g a day. The Eternal Elixir label serve is 2,000 mg in three capsules, and the product page suggests taking all three in the evening if sleep is the priority.
The trade-off is cost and elemental dose. A three-capsule serve supplies about 144 mg of elemental magnesium for $2.00 a day, while Healthy Care Magnesium Glycinate supplies 160 mg in one tablet for $0.27. If your aim is only to top up dietary magnesium, a glycinate tablet is the cheaper way to do it. Our magnesium L-threonate comparison sets this product against six others sold in Australia.
Key specs: 2,000 mg magnesium L-threonate per three-capsule serve · 90 capsules (30 days) · $59.99 · $2.00 per day · one active ingredient, no proprietary blend.
Pros:
- The magnesium form used in the 2024 sleep trial
- Compound weight printed on the label, with one active ingredient
- Every batch third-party lab tested, with the batch certificate sent on request
Cons:
- Highest daily cost in this list
- Less elemental magnesium per serve than a glycinate tablet
- Three capsules a day
Best for: people who want magnesium for sleep and focus in the form studied for the brain. Shop Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg.
#2. Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg — Best for daily stress and mood support
Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg is the stress and mood pick among Healthy Care alternatives, set against the brand’s L-theanine products. Each capsule holds 30 mg of affron®, a saffron stigma extract standardised to 3.5% Lepticrosalides®. One capsule a day from a 90-capsule bottle costs $0.56, the lowest daily price among the stress and mood products in this comparison.
affron® has two Australian trials behind it. In a 2017 study in Complementary Therapies in Medicine, 128 adults with self-reported low mood took 28 mg of affron® a day, 22 mg a day or a placebo for four weeks. The 28 mg group showed a drop in negative mood and stress-related scores against placebo, while the 22 mg group showed no effect. A 2020 trial in the Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine gave 63 adults with self-reported poor sleep 14 mg twice a day or a placebo for 28 days, and saffron was linked with better sleep-quality scores. The first study was co-authored by staff of the extract’s maker and the second was funded by it. Both relied on questionnaires.
Healthy Care L-Theanine + Ashwagandha costs four cents a day more and works through different ingredients: an amino acid found in tea and a herb from Ayurvedic tradition. Saffron suits people who want one capsule with a meal each morning. For a wider look at the saffron products sold here, see our saffron supplements comparison.
Key specs: 30 mg affron® per capsule · 90 capsules (90 days) · $49.99 · $0.56 per day.
Pros:
- Matches the 28 to 30 mg daily range used in the published trials
- Lowest daily price among the stress and mood products here
- One capsule a day from a three-month bottle
Cons:
- The trials ran for four weeks, so long-term data is thin
- No L-theanine for people who already rely on it
Best for: people who want a once-a-day capsule for stress and mood at a low daily cost. Try Saffron Extract 30mg.
#3. Eternal Elixir TUDCA 500mg — Best for a bile acid approach to liver health
Eternal Elixir TUDCA 500mg is the liver health alternative for people comparing Healthy Care Liver Care Advanced Plus or Liver Detox. Healthy Care’s liver products are built on milk thistle, with globe artichoke and dandelion added in the Advanced Plus formula. TUDCA (tauroursodeoxycholic acid) is a bile acid made by joining ursodeoxycholic acid to taurine, and Eternal Elixir sells it as a single ingredient in 500 mg capsules.
One capsule a day from a 90-capsule bottle costs $0.67, about twice the $0.35 a day of Liver Care Advanced Plus. The extra cost buys a different compound. Milk thistle has a long record of use in Western herbal medicine for the liver, and Healthy Care’s label says as much. TUDCA is newer as a stand-alone supplement, so it has less traditional-use history behind it. Our TUDCA, NAC and milk thistle comparison explains how the three differ, and our liver support supplements roundup covers the wider category.
If you take regular medicines, talk to your GP or pharmacist before adding any liver product, herbal or otherwise.
Key specs: 500 mg TUDCA per capsule · 90 capsules (90 days) · $59.99 · $0.67 per day.
Pros:
- One ingredient at a full 500 mg
- One capsule a day from a three-month bottle
- Every batch third-party lab tested
Cons:
- About twice the daily cost of Liver Care Advanced Plus
- Less traditional-use history than milk thistle
Best for: people who want a single-ingredient bile acid as part of a liver-friendly routine. View TUDCA 500mg.
#4. Eternal Elixir Trans-Resveratrol 600mg — Best for the lowest cost per 100 mg of resveratrol
Eternal Elixir Trans-Resveratrol 600mg is the alternative to Healthy Care Resveratrol Capsule for people who buy resveratrol for healthy ageing. Each capsule holds 600 mg of resveratrol at 98% trans-resveratrol, from Polygonum cuspidatum root. Healthy Care’s capsule holds 25 mg of resveratrol from Reynoutria japonica, which is the same plant (Japanese knotweed) under its current botanical name, plus grape seed extract and 100 mg of vitamin C.
Per 100 mg of resveratrol, Eternal Elixir costs $0.11 and Healthy Care costs $0.43, so the Eternal Elixir bottle is the cheaper source on that measure. Healthy Care is cheaper per day only because its daily amount is much smaller, at 50 to 100 mg. The best-known memory trial used 200 mg a day. In a 2014 study in The Journal of Neuroscience, 46 healthy, overweight adults aged 50 to 75 took 200 mg of resveratrol or a placebo for 26 weeks, and the resveratrol group retained more words over 30 minutes. One 600 mg capsule sits above that dose. Our resveratrol dosage guide covers how people choose an amount.
Key specs: 600 mg trans-resveratrol per capsule · 90 capsules (90 days) · $59.99 · $0.67 per day.
Pros:
- Lowest cost per 100 mg of resveratrol in this comparison
- 98% trans form, with one active ingredient
- One capsule a day
Cons:
- A higher daily dose than the 200 mg used in the 2014 memory trial
- No vitamin C or grape seed in the capsule
Best for: people who want a full dose of trans-resveratrol at a low cost per milligram. Buy Trans-Resveratrol 600mg.
Skip the comparison and buy direct. Eternal Elixir’s Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg ships from Australia in 90-capsule bottles, with free shipping over $100. Browse the range →
#5. Healthy Care Good Night Sleep (Magnesium + Ashwagandha) — Best for the lowest nightly price
Healthy Care Good Night Sleep (Magnesium + Ashwagandha) is the Healthy Care product most likely to be compared with a magnesium sleep capsule. Each capsule holds 500 mg of magnesium amino acid chelate (100 mg elemental magnesium), 75 mg of magnolia bark extract, 66.67 mg of ashwagandha root extract, 50 mg each of German chamomile and passionflower extracts, and 2.06 mg of vitamin B6. The direction is one to two capsules an hour before bed, so the 100-capsule bottle lasts 50 to 100 nights. At $23.99 that is $0.24 to $0.48 a night, the lowest nightly price among the sleep products here.
It suits someone who wants traditional sleep herbs and a modest magnesium dose in one capsule, though each herbal extract is small. Herbal sleep products can add to the effect of other sedating medicines, so check with your GP or pharmacist if you take any. Our guide on how to get more deep sleep covers the habits that matter before any capsule.
Pros:
- Lowest nightly price among the sleep products here
- Magnesium and four herbal extracts in one capsule
- Flexible one or two capsule dose
Cons:
- 100 mg of elemental magnesium per capsule, a modest amount
- Six actives in one capsule, so no single dose can be changed
- Chelate form, which is different from the threonate form used in the 2024 sleep trial
Best for: people who want a low-cost night capsule that combines herbs with magnesium.
#6. Healthy Care Magnesium Glycinate — Best for the most elemental magnesium per tablet
Healthy Care Magnesium Glycinate (120 tablets) is the plain magnesium choice in the range. Each tablet holds 1.14 g of magnesium glycinate, equal to 160 mg of elemental magnesium, the most per tablet in this list. The label suggests one tablet a day for general health and two for muscle cramp, mild muscle spasm and stress support, so the bottle lasts 60 to 120 days. At $32.99 that is $0.27 to $0.55 a day.
Two tablets give 320 mg of elemental magnesium. The adult upper level for magnesium taken as a supplement is 350 mg a day under the Australian and New Zealand Nutrient Reference Values, so two tablets plus another magnesium product could pass it. Glycinate is a sensible form for topping up intake. If you are choosing between glycinate and threonate, our magnesium L-threonate vs glycinate guide compares them side by side.
Pros:
- 160 mg of elemental magnesium per tablet
- Low daily cost
- Glycinate form, which the label positions as better absorbed than oxide
Cons:
- Two tablets come close to the 350 mg supplement upper level
- No sleep herbs and no threonate
Best for: people who want an affordable daily magnesium top-up.
#7. Healthy Care L-Theanine + Ashwagandha — Best for L-theanine and ashwagandha in one tablet
Healthy Care L-Theanine + Ashwagandha pairs 200 mg of AlphaWave® L-theanine with 240 mg of ashwagandha root extract, which the label says is equivalent to 10.8 g of dry root. The direction is one a day with a meal, so 60 tablets last 60 days. At $35.99 that is $0.60 a day, four cents more than Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg.
Healthy Care also sells High Strength L-Theanine 450 at $1.13 a day for a larger single dose. Ashwagandha does not suit everyone, so read the label warnings and check with your GP or pharmacist if you take regular medicines. Our cortisol supplements comparison covers these ingredients in more depth.
Pros:
- Two calming ingredients in one tablet
- One a day from a two-month bottle
- Named L-theanine ingredient (AlphaWave®)
Cons:
- Four cents a day dearer than the Eternal Elixir saffron capsule
- Ashwagandha does not suit everyone
Best for: people who already like L-theanine and want ashwagandha in the same tablet.
#8. Healthy Care Liver Care Advanced Plus 42000mg — Best for a three-herb liver formula at $0.35 a day
Healthy Care Liver Care Advanced Plus 42000mg is the main liver formula in the range. Each capsule holds 600 mg of milk thistle fruit extract (from 42 g of dried fruit), 100 mg of globe artichoke leaf extract and 30 mg of dandelion root extract. One capsule a day from a 100-capsule bottle at $35.09 costs $0.35, the lowest daily cost among the ranked liver products.
Milk thistle, artichoke and dandelion all have a history in Western herbal medicine for digestion and the liver, and the label describes them that way. The cheaper Healthy Care Liver Detox holds 178.6 mg of milk thistle seed extract with taurine and inositol, at $25.19 for 100 capsules ($0.25 to $0.50 a day at one to two capsules). Our TUDCA supplements comparison lists the single-ingredient TUDCA products sold in Australia for anyone weighing a switch.
Pros:
- One capsule a day
- Three herbs, each with a stated extract weight
- $0.35 a day
Cons:
- The 42000mg headline is the dried-fruit equivalent
- Three herbs in one capsule, so no single dose can be adjusted
Best for: people who prefer a traditional milk thistle formula at a low daily cost.
#9. Healthy Care Resveratrol Capsule — Best for the lowest shelf price
Healthy Care Resveratrol Capsule costs $19.19 for 180 capsules, the lowest shelf price in this list. Each capsule holds 50 mg of Reynoutria japonica root extract, equal to 25 mg of resveratrol, with 41.67 mg of grape seed extract and 100 mg of vitamin C. The direction is two to four capsules a day with a meal, which gives 50 to 100 mg of resveratrol for $0.21 to $0.43 a day.
The label states resveratrol without saying how much of it is the trans form. Reaching the 200 mg a day used in the 2014 memory trial would take eight capsules, which is above the label direction. As a small daily amount with vitamin C included, it is good value. For a fuller dose, see our resveratrol supplements comparison.
Pros:
- Lowest shelf price in this list
- Vitamin C and grape seed included
- Flexible two to four capsule dose
Cons:
- 25 mg of resveratrol per capsule
- Trans form not stated on the label
- $0.43 per 100 mg of resveratrol, almost four times the Eternal Elixir cost
Best for: people who want a small daily amount of resveratrol at the lowest price.
Editor’s Choice
Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg — the magnesium form tested for deep and REM sleep scores in a 2024 placebo-controlled trial, in one evening serve of three capsules for $2.00 a day.
Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg · $59.99 AUD · 90 capsules, 30 days
Magnesium Dose Check: Healthy Care Labels Against the Daily Limit
Shoppers comparing Healthy Care alternatives for magnesium often own more than one magnesium product, so it helps to add them up. The adult upper level for magnesium taken as a supplement is 350 mg a day for men and women alike. The recommended dietary intake from all sources is 400 to 420 mg a day for men and 310 to 320 mg for women. The supplement limit exists because too much magnesium from supplements can cause diarrhoea. This is what each magnesium product mentioned here supplies at its top label dose.
| Product | Elemental magnesium per unit | Top label dose | Elemental magnesium at top dose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg | About 48 mg per capsule | 3 capsules | About 144 mg |
| Healthy Care Good Night Sleep | 100 mg per capsule | 2 capsules | 200 mg |
| Healthy Care Super Bio Magnesium | 300 mg per capsule (oxide and phosphate) | 1 capsule | 300 mg |
| Healthy Care Magnesium Glycinate | 160 mg per tablet | 2 tablets | 320 mg |
| Healthy Care Ultra Magnesium Triple Complex | 200 mg per tablet | 2 tablets | 400 mg |
Ultra Magnesium Triple Complex at two tablets passes the 350 mg supplement limit on its own, so keep to one tablet unless a health professional advises otherwise. A glycinate tablet in the morning and two Good Night Sleep capsules at night would also pass it. Magnesium L-threonate supplies less elemental magnesium per serve, which makes it easier to fit alongside a magnesium-rich diet. Our sleep supplements comparison lists other ways to approach a better night.
How We Evaluated These Healthy Care Alternatives
We chose these Healthy Care alternatives by starting from the Healthy Care products in categories where Eternal Elixir makes a product, and kept five that had a live price on healthycare.com.au on 2 November 2026. Labels and directions came from the same product pages. Eternal Elixir prices, stock and serving sizes came from our own store on the same day. Each product was then weighed on five criteria:
- Quality and label clarity (30%): single-ingredient doses, stated extract weights and standardised actives
- Australian availability and shipping (20%)
- Price per day in AUD at the label’s own directions (20%)
- Range for stacking (15%)
- Research on the ingredient at the dose supplied, and brand reputation (15%)
Eternal Elixir products take the top four places. We make them, and they lead on label clarity and on the research behind each ingredient at the dose in the capsule. They also cost more per day in three of the four categories, and each Healthy Care entry says where it wins on price. This is a comparison written by a brand with products in it, and the scoring is ours. For the same format applied to another pharmacy brand, see our Cenovis alternatives guide.
Healthy Care Alternatives: Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best Healthy Care alternative in Australia?
For sleep and magnesium, Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg is our pick. It uses the magnesium form studied for deep and REM sleep scores, in a 2,000 mg serve for $2.00 a day. For stress and mood, Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg gives 30 mg of affron® for $0.56 a day. Eternal Elixir makes both.
Is Healthy Care a good brand?
Healthy Care prints both the extract weight and the dried-herb equivalent on its labels, and its single-nutrient products such as Magnesium Glycinate state the elemental dose clearly. Its shelf prices are low. The large headline numbers on its herbal products describe the raw material, so compare products on the extract weight and the cost per day at the label dose.
What does 42000mg mean on Healthy Care Liver Care Advanced Plus?
It is the weight of dried milk thistle fruit used to make the extract. Each capsule holds 600 mg of milk thistle extract, made at a 70 to 1 ratio from 42 g of dried fruit, with globe artichoke and dandelion extracts alongside it.
Is Healthy Care cheaper than Eternal Elixir?
Per bottle, yes, and per day in most categories. Healthy Care Magnesium Glycinate costs $0.27 to $0.55 a day against $2.00 for Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate, and Liver Care Advanced Plus costs $0.35 a day against $0.67 for TUDCA. The exceptions are stress and mood, where Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg is four cents a day cheaper than L-Theanine + Ashwagandha, and resveratrol per 100 mg, where Eternal Elixir costs $0.11 against $0.43.
How much magnesium can I take from supplements each day?
The adult upper level for magnesium from supplements in Australia and New Zealand is 350 mg a day, with food counted separately. Add up every product you take using the elemental magnesium figure on each label, and stay under 350 mg unless a health professional advises otherwise.
Can I take magnesium L-threonate and saffron together?
They are different ingredients with no shared active, and Eternal Elixir sells both in its Brain, Mood and Sleep Stack. The product pages suggest one saffron capsule a day with a meal, and all three magnesium L-threonate capsules in the evening when sleep is the priority. If you take regular medicines, check the combination with your GP or pharmacist first.
How long should I try a supplement before judging it?
Use the trial lengths as a guide: 21 days in the 2024 magnesium L-threonate sleep trial, four weeks in the 2017 affron® mood trial and 26 weeks in the 2014 resveratrol memory study. Keep a short note of sleep, mood or energy from the first day so you have something to compare against.
The Verdict on Healthy Care Alternatives
Healthy Care is a low-cost range with clear labels once you read past the headline numbers. Among Healthy Care alternatives, Eternal Elixir Magnesium L-Threonate 2000mg is our top pick for sleep. It costs more per day, and it gives you the magnesium form used in the 2024 sleep trial. Eternal Elixir Saffron Extract 30mg is the daily stress and mood option at $0.56. TUDCA 500mg suits people who want a bile acid in place of milk thistle, and Trans-Resveratrol 600mg is the cheaper source of resveratrol per 100 mg.
If the price per bottle decides it for you, the Healthy Care originals win over the Healthy Care alternatives above, and Good Night Sleep and Magnesium Glycinate are hard to beat for general magnesium intake. If you are building a routine across sleep and mood, the two Eternal Elixir capsules together cost $2.56 a day, and orders over $100 ship free within Australia. For another big-brand comparison, see our Swisse alternatives guide.
More buying guides
Magnesium L-Threonate Supplements in Australia Compared → Blackmores Alternatives Australia: Sleep, Mood and Liver → Top Australian Supplement Brands →Start your sleep stack today
90 capsules per bottle · Australian shipping · Third-party tested
Find your routine in 60 seconds →Finish the quiz for 20% off your first order. Or Shop Eternal Elixir →
Recommended for you
About Eternal Elixir
Eternal Elixir is an Australian supplement company specialising in longevity and nootropic formulations. Every batch is third-party lab tested, and the batch Certificate of Analysis is sent on request. Browse the full range at eternalelixir.com.au/shop.
Not sure what to take? Take our 8-question quiz
to unlock 20% OFF your entire first order
+ a FREE gift worth up to $59.99



